Adobe Robohelp

Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscriber count: 3,220

Adobe Robohelp

Grammar Girl Podcast — Some Thoughts on Grammar as a Topic for a Podcast

Feb 26, 2007 • general

Grammar Girl is the latest subject of the DMN Communications podcast. The Grammar Girl podcast covers ... you guessed it, grammar. What's surprising is the popularity of this podcast. The popularity prompts a thought-provoking question: in a world of degenerating language, where sentences are massacred in text messages, poorly written blog posts, reader comments, user forums, and other social media, why does anyone care so much about grammar?

Yet apparently people are eating this podcast up. It was one of the top podcasts on iTunes for a while, on the same playing field as ChinesePod and Ask a Ninja. Part of the appeal of the Grammar Girl podcast, whose tagline is "Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing," is the brevity and focus of the show. But mostly people want to make sure their writing is correct. In the minds of many, correct grammar = good writing. I once worked for someone who asked me to guarantee that the copy I edited was 100% free of grammar errors, as if that ensured quality.

The late Charles Darling's site on grammar was one of the most popular on the Internet. He responded to thousands of questions about grammar that users submitted. When I was an composition instructor, I created a site that contained a bit of grammar instruction. The site covers more than grammar, but it still receives about 1,500 hits a day.

Some classics have been written on grammar — Fowler's Modern English Usage, Strunk and White on The Elements of Style, the Chicago Manual of Style. In a Brian Oberkirch interview with Guy Kawasaki, Guy explains he wishes he could write a classic and names the last two (Elements of Style and the Chicago Manual of Style), as if they epitomized timeless prose.

Personally, although I occasionally listen to the grammar girl podcast, I don't find it that compelling. She seems to read a script and often times plunges through some thick concepts and rules, which require full concentration. You do feel like you're learning, or at least reinforcing your knowledge (definitely an appeal for podcasts). And she does include examples and mnemonics. But I find it dry. There's not much debate or depth, and I'm wondering how long the show will last. At some point she'll be repeating the same content or will be forced to reach further and further into the arcane. Nevertheless, she is also shaping, on a large scale, the language of the Internet. So for that, I say thank you Grammar Girl.


Get new posts delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscriber count: 3,220

About Tom Johnson

Tom Johnson

I'm a technical writer based in the California San Francisco Bay area. Topics I write about on this blog include technical writing, authoring and publishing tools, API documentation, tech comm trends, visual communication, technical writing career advice, information architecture and findability, developer documentation, and more. If you're a professional or aspiring technical writer, be sure to subscribe to email updates using the form above. You can learn more about me here.