Tag Archives: DITA

Is Structured Authoring (like DITA) a Good Fit for Publishing on a Website?

May 22, 2013 Update: This post generated a lot of controversy, and I believe part of the controversy could have been avoided if I had articulated my ideas better. I’ve gone through and updated parts of this post by adding notes.  5/22 note: Previous title was “Structured Authoring Versus the Web”. However, of course the Continue Reading »

Why Long Topics Are Better for the User

In my previous post, Do Short Topics Make Information More Findable, I argued that shorter topics make it more difficult for users to find information. I ended the post by saying that topics that are more substantial make content more findable. But how big should the topics be? Obviously not the length of a book, Continue Reading »

Do Short Topics Make Information More Findable?

In my last post, which now has more than 80 comments, I noted that authoring with DITA seemed to encourage authors to create a lot of little topics. DITA experts chimed in to say DITA doesn’t constrain users with topic length in their outputs — authors can combine topics as needed. However, one commenter noted that short Continue Reading »

Does DITA Encourage Authors to Fragment Information into a Million Little Pieces?

I’m currently exploring the possibility of authoring content in DITA (using a tool such as easyDITA), publishing to an HTML web help output (through the DITA Open Toolkit), and then importing the output into Drupal (through some Python scripts someone has created). This sounds like a good workflow to me, but I’ve kind of run Continue Reading »

Unconscious Meaning Suggested from the Structure and Shape of Help

I’m continuing to make my way through James Kalbach’s book, Designing Web Navigation. In chapter 2, he says the structure and format of content helps users anticipate the meaning of the content. He writes, The human visual system naturally seeks structure in information, often very rapidly. Scientists refer to this as “pre-attentive” processing. This occurs Continue Reading »

Wiki Culture, Reader/Writer Distinctions, and Divergence from Structured Authoring

In my last post on wikis, Mark Baker added an astute comment: I’m not a wiki fan myself — I’m a structured text guy bred in the bone — but I am fascinated by the trend, and by the variety reactions to it. Wikis started more as a cultural statement than a technology. They were Continue Reading »

The Importance of Chunking for Sorting

If you want to be able to sort information by various classification schemes, such as by most popular, or by role, or by problem, your content has to be chunked in a granular enough way to facilitate the various means of sorting. Consider a work that is one large book, with no chunks at all. Continue Reading »

Arguments for and Against Tripane Help

My colleague Ben Minson wrote a post about why tripane help is a relic of the book-paradigm documentation age, and how it can limit us from taking advantage of other web technologies. See Why I Don’t Like Tri-pane Help. As a quick definition, tripane help is the standard webhelp HTML output that has several frames Continue Reading »